1885 – 1886 V.H. Velsor *

1887 – 1893 J.H. Berry *

1893 – 1894 Smith Wright *

1894 – 1906 Charles Brown *

1906 – 1907 Eugene Smith *

1908 – 1909 W. Clayton Haff *

1909 – 1910 Willis P. Raynor *

1910 – 1912 Charles Suydam *

1912 – 1913 John A. Gates *

1913 – 1914 Alfred Doxsee *

1914 – 1916 J. Preston Smith *

1916 – 1919 Charles Bollinger *

1919 – 1921 Clayton Grover *

1921 – 1922 Hewlett Raynor *

1922 – 1923 Frank Howland *

1923 – 1927 Harry Brown *

1927 – 1930 William Albertina *

1930 – 1935 John Dempsey *

1935 – 1937 Lawrence Peterson *

1937 – 1940 John Kasin *

1940 – 1942 Herman Beebe *

1942 – 1944 James Murphy *

1944 – 1946 Herbert Albertina *

1946 – 1948 Amerigo Zarcone *

1948 – 1950 Christopher Wetzler *

1950 – 1952 Donald Sullivan *

1952 – 1954 Ernest Gale *

1954 – 1956 Milton Riedel *

1956 – 1958 Paul Kjar *

1958 – 1960 John Stecker *

1960 – 1962 Jack kahler *

1962 – 1964 Henry Hohmann *

1964 – 1966 Charles Mews *

1966 – 1968 Frank Matousek *

1968 – 1970 John E. Kasin *

1970 – 1972 John Mueller *

1972 – 1974 Benjamin Gelletto

1974 – 1976 Robert Ballarine *

1976 – 1978 Charles Flower *

1978 – 1980 Edwin Corwin *

1980 – 1982 Richard Ackerson Sr.

1982 – 1984 Frank Slavik 

1984 – 1986 Leonard Tinelli *

1986 – 1988 Terrence Savoy *

1988 – 1990 Thomas J. Butler 

1990 – 1992 A. Wayne Overton

1992 – 1994 Robert Powers

1994 – 1996 Richard Ackerson Jr. *

1996 – 1998 Charles Farrell

1998 – 2000 James Delle Femine *

2000 – 2002 Vincent K. Dineen *

2002 – 2004 Jens G. Golden 

2004 – 2006 Phillip J. Dineen

2006 – 2007 Thomas Farrell

2007 – 2009 Joseph S. Marino

2010 – 2011 Richard J. Patch Jr.

2012 – 2013 William P. Stenger

2014 – 2015 Carmine V. Paolicelli

2016 - 2017 William P. Moon II *

2018 - 2019 Thomas J. Butler Sr.

2020 - 2021 Ronald E. Pfuhl

2022 - 2023 Alden J. Schroeder

* Deceased